唱歌呼吸的常見迷思：為甚麼空氣過多會損害你的嗓音？

你是否常聽到「深呼吸才能唱好歌」？這句話聽起來很有道理，但事實上，太多空氣用力推送反而會傷害聲帶，讓聲音變得模糊疲勞。現代聲樂科學強調，唱歌時的呼吸不是追求大口氣，而是靈活回應聲帶與音色的需求，讓氣流與聲音完美配合。

迷思一：聲音來自空氣

很多人以為多吸氣就有大聲音，但空氣本身不會發聲。聲音是由喉嚨內的聲帶（vocal folds）振動產生，它們需要適量氣流來震動，卻也得緊密接觸才能發出清晰音色。如果氣壓過大，聲帶會被吹開，導致氣聲、不穩定的音質，甚至聲帶疲勞。重點是控制氣流，而不是盲目吸更多氣。​

迷思二：呼吸獨立於聲音

呼吸不是獨立的動作，它得隨音量、高音低音、音色變化而調整。像Estill聲樂訓練系統教導，氣流要回應聲帶的閉合時間、振動速度，以及喉嚨與嘴巴的形狀變化。強行推送氣流只會讓一切變得僵硬，高效唱歌靠的是氣流、聲帶與聲道的動態協調。

迷思三：用橫膈膜呼吸

「用橫膈膜唱歌」是老生常談，但我們日常呼吸本來就靠它，甚至睡覺時也自動運作。問題不在激活橫膈膜，而在管理氣流壓力，避免過度用力。聲樂訓練的重點是整體氣息控制，讓聲音持久不累，而不是執著單一肌肉。​

迷思四：腹式還是胸式？

腹式呼吸還是胸式？這辯論永遠沒完，但沒有一種是絕對正確。無論哪種吸氣，都會影響喉頭位置，高音或特定音色可能需要不同調整。好的歌手需要靈活性，讓呼吸快速適應聲音需求，而不是固定姿勢。​

迷思五：傳統呼吸練習萬能

像長發「s」音的練習常見，但這時聲帶是張開的，氣壓高，不像真唱歌時的振動狀態。更好的是結合聲音的訓練，例如半閉塞聲道練習（SOVTEs），如唇顫（lip trills）、吸管唱歌或「z」音延長。它們能平衡氣壓與聲帶互動，但最好在專業老師指導下練習。​

迷思六：用力推送氣流？

一開始吐氣時，肺部自然彈性就夠用，不需推。但長音句末尾，可能需腹部或肋骨肌肉輔助，就像用完車子油箱的最後一滴。關鍵是分辨何時放鬆、何時介入，沒有萬用規則。​

真正原則：沒有永恆規則

唱歌呼吸因樂句、長音、高低音、明暗音色而異，舊教條源自科學不發達的年代。現在我們明白，聲樂成功靠彈性協調：聲帶高效接觸、聲道靈活調整、氣流順勢回應。如果聲音常累或不穩，多半是氣太多而非太少。

記住，力量來自平衡，不是蠻力。​

---

Breathing Myths in Singing: Why Too Much Air Can Harm Your Voice

When people think about improving their voice  (for singing, public speaking, or performance ) the first advice they usually hear is:“Take a deep breath.”

It sounds logical. More air should mean more power, right?

Not exactly.

In reality, many vocal problems don’t come from too little breath, but from too much air pushed with too much force. Modern voice science shows that breathing for voice isn’t about “big breaths,” but about responsive airflow that adjusts to what the vocal system is doing.

Let’s break down some of the the biggest breathing myths in voice training, and what actually works.

Myth 1: Sound Comes from Air

Air is necessary! But air does not create sound by itself.

Sound happens when the vocal folds (often called vocal cords,  two small folds of tissue inside the larynx) come together and vibrate as air passes through them.

They need airflow to vibrate, yes.But they also need to stay in contact long enough to produce a clear, efficient sound.

When too much air is pushed with excessive pressure, the folds can be blown apart, making vibration less efficient. The result?

• Breathy or unstable sound

• Vocal fatigue

• A feeling of “pushing” or strain

More air does not mean more sound.Often, it means less control and more effort.

Myth 2: Breathing Is Separate from the Rest of the Voice

Breathing doesn’t happen in isolation. It must constantly adjust to what the voice is doing.

In modern voice training systems such as Estill Voice Training, airflow is understood as something that responds to changing vocal conditions:

• Volume: Louder sounds often involve vocal folds staying closed longer during each vibration cycle

• Pitch: Higher notes require faster vibrations

• Tone quality / vocal color: Brighter, darker, breathier, or clearer sounds all require different adjustments

• Vowels and consonants: The vocal tract, including the pharynx (throat) and mouth,  constantly changes shape

• Vocal color choices: Subtle shifts in resonance and timbre come from changes in the shape and space of the vocal tract

All these adjustments affect how air should flow.

If airflow is pushed too hard, it becomes rigid instead of adaptive.But efficient voice use depends on flexible, dynamic interaction between breath, vocal folds, and the vocal tract.

Breathing for voice is not about force.It’s about coordination.

Myth 3: You should breath with Your Diaphragm

Almost everyone has heard this:“Sing from your diaphragm.”

Here’s the truth:You already breathe with your diaphragm. Everyone does. Even while sleeping.

The diaphragm is an automatic breathing muscle, and we have limited direct control over it. Singing is not about “activating” the diaphragm more. It’s about:

• Managing airflow efficiently

• Avoiding excessive pressure

• Using breath in a sustainable way

  
  

In fact, very little of what we consciously adjust in voice training happens at the diaphragm itself. The key is overall breath management, not diaphragm obsession.

Myth 4: Belly vs. Chest (The Great Debate)

Should you breathe into your belly or into your chest when singing or speaking?

This is the wrong question.Every type of inhalation influences the rest of the body including the larynx (voice box). For example:

If you place your fingers gently on your larynx and take a very large “belly breath,” you may feel it move slightly downward. That change in position can be helpful for some sounds and unhelpful for others.

Different styles, pitches, and tone colors may benefit from different laryngeal positions.

So instead of choosing one “correct” breathing style, we need flexibility.Good vocal breathing is dynamic. It supports the voice in reaching the right configuration quickly, not in staying locked into one posture.

Myth 5: Traditional Breathing Exercises Are Always Helpful

Classic breathing drills often involve making a long /s/ sound.

But during /s/, the vocal folds are open, and air pressure can be quite high. That does not reflect how the voice actually works during speaking or singing, where the folds vibrate and regulate airflow.

Breathing for voice should be trained with the voice.

There are many effective strategies to develop more responsive airflow. For example, when there is too much pressure and the voice feels strained, exercises known as semi-occluded vocal tract exercises (SOVTEs) can help.

Common examples include:

• Lip trills

• Singing through a straw

• Sustaining sounds like /z/

These are just a few among many possible SOVTE variations used in voice training.They help balance air pressure and vocal fold interaction. However, each exercise has a specific purpose and should ideally be used under the guidance of a knowledgeable vocal trainer.

Myth 6: Push!

Should You Push the Air or Let It Go Naturally?

The answer is: it depends.

At the start of an exhalation, air flows out naturally due to elastic recoil in the lungs and ribcage. No pushing is required.

But during a very long phrase — whether in singing or extended speech — we may need to use the last portion of available air, similar to using a car’s fuel reserve. That final portion does not come out as easily and may require more active involvement from abdominal or ribcage muscles.

So again, there is no single rule. The key is learning when to stay passive and when to assist.

The Real Principle: No Breathing Rule Is Always Right

There is no breathing action that is always correct or always wrong.What works at the beginning of a phrase may not work at the end.What works for a low note may not work for a high note.A dark tone, a bright tone, a breathy sound, and a clear tone all require different relationships with airflow.

Many traditional breathing dogmas come from earlier centuries, when voice science could not yet explain how airflow, vocal fold vibration, and vocal tract shape interact.

Today we know that effective voice use is not about rigid rules.It’s about elastic, responsive coordination.

The goal is not to “breathe more.”It’s to breathe in a way that adapts instantly to what your voice needs.

Key Takeaway

If your voice feels tired, strained, or unstable, the problem may not be a lack of air: the problem mighe be too much air pushed without coordination.

Better voice performance comes from:

• Efficient vocal fold contact

• Flexible vocal tract adjustments

• Breath that responds, not dominates

  
  

In voice, power doesn’t come from force.It comes from balance.

About the author

Adjunct Professor in Performing Arts Medicine (Università Niccolò Cusano) and EMCI–TPSD (Estill Mentor & Course Instructor, Testing Privileges and Service Distinction), Francesco works at the intersection of vocal science, pedagogy, and performance psychology. He has trained performers from Tokyo to New York, coached artists from Broadway to K-pop, and teaches Estill Voice Training in seven languages. Appointed by Estill Voice International as the Chairman of the 2027 Estill World Voice Symposium in Hong Kong, the first to be hosted in Asia, he is shaping a new chapter in global voice education.